Authors: Anna Kuts, Legal Advisor at Transparency International Ukraine

Pavlo Demchuk, Senior Legal Advisor at Transparency International Ukraine

The selection of a manager for the assets of IDS Ukraine (Morshynska and Myrhorodska) is one of the first real cases in which a manager for a complex asset was sought under the new rules of the Law on ARMA. That is exactly why the way this selection unfolded, and the problems it ran into, deserve close study. 

The assets in question are blocks of shares in Myrhorod Mineral Water Plant PJSC and Morshyn Mineral Water Plant Oskar PJSC. Their market value exceeds UAH 5 billion, and their net revenue from product sales in 2025 was approximately UAH 10 billion. 

However, the first attempt did not go smoothly. The selection revealed shortcomings and gaps that can and should be fixed in the future. 

A detailed analysis of the entire procedure is already available on the Transparency International Ukraine website. This article offers only specific recommendations for future participants and for the organizer of selections for the next complex assets.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(129) "The first attempt did not go smoothly. The selection revealed shortcomings and gaps that can and should be fixed in the future. " ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

The first attempt did not go smoothly. The selection revealed shortcomings and gaps that can and should be fixed in the future. 

What participants should have considered before the start

The very first attempt to find a manager failed: only one company, HOTEI RESPECT LLC, applied to the selection announced in May. The law does not allow an asset to be handed over to a sole applicant without competition, so ARMA announced the selection again. Participants could, and had to, assess the terms of this repeat selection in advance.

  • The mandatory qualification requirement under the Law on ARMA is at least three years of experience in leasing movable and immovable property or acting as an intermediary in leasing. This requirement is a formality: any business entity that has officially leased out property for three years meets it, and it says nothing about the ability to run a large business.
  • An additional requirement set by the Commission was management experience in FMCG (fast-moving consumer goods), the food industry, distribution, corporate rights, or large enterprises. It could be confirmed by almost any document, including a free-form statement.
  • Safeguards common to all selections: a participant may not be connected to the asset owner, to persons involved in the criminal proceedings, or to the aggressor state; may not be under sanctions; may not have tax arrears exceeding 100 minimum wages; may not be on the blacklist of the AMCU, be bankrupt, and so on. The participant’s officers must not have been held liable for corruption or convicted of money laundering or crimes committed for gain. In addition, the law bars participation by anyone who produces or sells interchangeable goods, uses similar raw materials or fixed assets, or depends for pricing on the enterprise whose assets are being transferred into management.
  • Documents: the list was accessible and non-discriminatory, but it called for documents that state authorities do not issue, since they issue register extracts instead. Examples include a “certificate of no criminal record” and a “certificate of no corruption offenses.” A participant can draw up such a certificate on its own, which does not guarantee its accuracy. The permissible age of these certificates was not specified either.
  • The fee and its terms matter most to the economics of a bid. Participants had to state their desired fee, calculated as a percentage of profit, which could be as high as 100%. The winner was required to provide a bank guarantee of over UAH 100 million and pay UAH 5 million to the electronic platform. Insurance of the asset and third-party liability insurance also had to be factored in. These mandatory costs total roughly UAH 10 million, so each participant needed to compare this amount with the fee for which it was offering its services.

As a result, five participants applied for the selection. All of them were admitted to the auction, with no objections to their qualifications. During the auction, all participants cut their bids to abnormally low levels. This is where participants and organizers have the most to learn.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(258) "The very first attempt to find a manager failed: only one company, HOTEI RESPECT LLC, applied to the selection announced in May. The law does not allow an asset to be handed over to a sole applicant without competition, so ARMA announced the selection again." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

The very first attempt to find a manager failed: only one company, HOTEI RESPECT LLC, applied to the selection announced in May. The law does not allow an asset to be handed over to a sole applicant without competition, so ARMA announced the selection again.

Why the first auction winner was rejected

At the start of the auction, the bids of the five participants (Alliance D LLC, Ready-Invest Asset Management Company LLC, Prioritas Law Firm LLC, Yuvileinyi Meat Processing Plant LLC, and Ukrcapital Asset Management Company LLC) ranged from 30% to 80% of profit. After the auction, they ranged from 0.01% to 10%. This drop meant that all five companies met the criteria for an abnormally low bid. 

In such cases, the winner must justify its price with calculations showing how it plans to cut costs, what favorable conditions it has, or how it will increase revenue compared with the indicative management plan. If no justification is provided, the Commission must reject the bid. If the justification is inadequate, the Commission may reject it.

The auction was won by Ukrcapital Asset Management Company LLC with a fee of 0.01% of profit, or about UAH 110,000 per year. The company cited the fact that it needed no separate infrastructure, that it had a license and staff, and it presented scenarios of 10–15% profit growth. The Commission found the justification inadequate for three reasons:

  1. The fee did not cover mandatory costs. It was an order of magnitude lower than the mandatory costs associated with the contract: the fee to the electronic platform, the bank guarantee, and insurance. As noted above, these come to roughly UAH 10 million.
  2. The arguments concerned qualifications, not grounds for favorable conditions. A license and staff demonstrate compliance with requirements, which had already been checked at admission to the auction, whereas the Commission expected a justification of the price.
  3. There was no calculation of the effect of revenue-boosting tools. The 10–15% profit growth scenarios did not include any calculation of how, and by what methods, that growth would be achieved.

Importantly, the Commission assessed the justification on its merits rather than as a formality. Participants in future selections should therefore bear in mind that the bid they offer must be backed by calculations of costs and revenue sources, not merely by references to their existing resources.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(299) "Importantly, the Commission assessed the justification on its merits rather than as a formality. Participants in future selections should therefore bear in mind that the bid they offer must be backed by calculations of costs and revenue sources, not merely by references to their existing resources." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

Importantly, the Commission assessed the justification on its merits rather than as a formality. Participants in future selections should therefore bear in mind that the bid they offer must be backed by calculations of costs and revenue sources, not merely by references to their existing resources.

Questions about the Prioritas bid

Ultimately, Prioritas Law Firm LLC became the winner, with a fee of 0.9% of profit (approximately UAH 10 million per year). The Commission accepted its justification of the abnormally low bid, applying the same approach to both participants, including inviting their representatives to its meeting. Let us examine each element of the bid.

Basic qualification (three years of leasing)

The leasing documents show that the participant leased property to the Prioritas Attorneys’ Association, whose head is the same person who heads the participant. This is not formally prohibited, but it gives food for thought. The selection announcement required only the lease agreements, without payment documents, so whether payments were actually made remains unverified, even though ARMA had already applied such requirements in last year’s selections.

Additional requirement (management experience)

The ARMA Commission formulated the requirement for management experience in FMCG, the food industry, corporate rights, or large enterprises broadly and in a non-discriminatory manner. Formally, therefore, the Commission was obliged to take into account any documents on experience that were submitted, and it had no right to impose additional conditions after the submission deadline or to rank participants by experience.

Prioritas submitted two documents: its own statement on its involvement in Terra Incognita Group since 2015, and a letter of recommendation from that same company, signed by its director, who is appointed by its sole owner. These documents contain no figures or concrete results, only general wording. Thus the additional requirement, which was meant to offset the generality of the basic one, was in practice confirmed by documents drawn up by the participant itself and by a company it controls.

Certificates and questionnaire

The Prioritas questionnaire lacks some of the information about the authorized person, and the information certificate from the Register of Corrupt Officials concerned the legal entity rather than its officer. Under Resolution No. 167, ARMA should have posted a request in Prozorro to remedy these discrepancies instead of admitting the participant to the auction.

The fact that these issues were not addressed at the qualification stage is a problem with the selection announcement, not only with the participant. Prioritas met the requirements for confirming its experience exactly as the announcement required, and the announcement contained no prohibition on leasing to related companies and no requirement to demonstrate specific financial results of past management. 

Had the participant submitted false information material to determining the manager, this could not have been remedied, and the participant would have been found non-compliant. In this case, however, the Commission had no evidence that the information was false. Citing the limits of its powers, the Commission therefore asked ARMA to further verify the accuracy of the documents on experience before concluding the contract and, if there were signs of a criminal offense, to refer the matter to law enforcement.

Notably, on September 29, the Dnipropetrovsk District Administrative Court, acting on an application by another auction participant, Yuvileinyi Meat Processing Plant LLC, prohibited ARMA from concluding a contract with Prioritas. As of today, the group has no manager, and this is precisely why ARMA is not signing the management contract.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(339) "Notably, on September 29, the Dnipropetrovsk District Administrative Court, acting on an application by another auction participant, Yuvileinyi Meat Processing Plant LLC, prohibited ARMA from concluding a contract with Prioritas. As of today, the group has no manager, and this is precisely why ARMA is not signing the management contract." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

Notably, on September 29, the Dnipropetrovsk District Administrative Court, acting on an application by another auction participant, Yuvileinyi Meat Processing Plant LLC, prohibited ARMA from concluding a contract with Prioritas. As of today, the group has no manager, and this is precisely why ARMA is not signing the management contract.

The bottom line

The selection procedure has started to work: competition has emerged, and the Commission reviews justifications of abnormally low bids on their merits. The weak points are the requirements and the documents. These can be fixed in future selections by taking at least five steps:

  1. Correct document titles. Replace the “certificate of no criminal record” and the “certificate of no corruption offenses” with register extracts, and do the same for anticompetitive concerted actions. For non-residents, documents issued under the law of the country of origin, with a translation, should be required separately.
  2. Up-to-date documents. Set requirements on their age, for example, issued no earlier than 30 days before the selection is announced.
  3. Multi-level confirmation of additional experience requirements. A free-form statement should be required only together with other documents of the participant’s choice (projects, letters of recommendation, documents on participation in management). To prevent box-ticking compliance, additional criteria for successful management experience should be considered.
  4. Payment documents to confirm leasing experience. In addition to agreements, payment orders and bank notices should be required, as in ARMA’s previous selections. More broadly, since the leasing requirement is no indicator of management ability, the Law on ARMA should be amended to remove it from the list of requirements for potential managers of complex assets.

As of October 29, 2026, Prozorro lists 19 competitive selections. Only one ended with a contract being concluded, eight did not take place, and eight more are still accepting bids. It is therefore up to ARMA and the Commission how detailed and tailored the requirements for potential managers of each complex asset will be.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(323) "As of October 29, 2026, Prozorro lists 19 competitive selections. Only one ended with a contract being concluded, eight did not take place, and eight more are still accepting bids. It is therefore up to ARMA and the Commission how detailed and tailored the requirements for potential managers of each complex asset will be." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

As of October 29, 2026, Prozorro lists 19 competitive selections. Only one ended with a contract being concluded, eight did not take place, and eight more are still accepting bids. It is therefore up to ARMA and the Commission how detailed and tailored the requirements for potential managers of each complex asset will be.

Source: zn.ua