On November 12, the Verkhovna Rada Law Enforcement Committee recommended adopting government Draft Law No. 16026, which changes how prosecutors represent the interests of the state in court, both in first reading and as a whole.
TI Ukraine believes that, as currently drafted, the draft law could make it harder to gather evidence in civil forfeiture cases.
We therefore propose adopting it in first reading only and fixing the problematic provisions before the second.
At present, claims to declare assets unjustified and forfeit them to the state are filed by SAPO prosecutors and, in cases specified by law, by prosecutors of the Prosecutor General’s Office. To bring such a claim, a prosecutor must collect data on the person’s income and the value of their property before going to court.
Article 23(8) of the Law on the Prosecutor’s Office gives prosecutors direct access to the information systems, registers, and databases of state and local government bodies. The draft law replaces this with “special access.” Under the Law on Public Electronic Registers, that term covers only public registers, so holders of other databases may decide the provision does not apply to them.
SAPO prosecutors already struggle to obtain certain data in practice. The 2026 Shadow Report describes cases where some bodies refused to give prosecutors data on pensions, income, and social benefits, arguing that prosecutors have no right to request restricted information.
The draft law also changes the purpose of access: instead of “identifying” unjustified assets, it now speaks of “confirming their existence.” This is inconsistent with Article 290(5) of the Civil Procedure Code, which expressly tasks SAPO with identifying such assets.
In light of this, we propose to:
- retain prosecutors’ direct access to the registers and databases of state bodies for confirming the existence of unjustified assets and gathering evidence;
- enshrine the right to obtain, free of charge and on a reasoned written request, copies of documents and information, including restricted information, needed to establish lawful income, the value of assets, and the circumstances of their acquisition;
- specify what exactly a prosecutor must state in the request (the person, the information sought, the period) and how they justify the need for it.
We also note that the draft law raises concerns about the clarity of certain provisions, notably the list of “exceptional cases” in which prosecutors may represent the state’s interests in court. The Main Scientific and Expert Department of the Verkhovna Rada Secretariat makes the same point in its conclusions. These concerns should be addressed when Draft Law No. 16026 is prepared for second reading.
We therefore propose adopting it in first reading only and fixing the problematic provisions before the second.