Forensic examinations are a key part of investigations into high-level corruption. In the Midas case alone, more than 50 examinations were ordered, and not all of them went smoothly. According to Oleksandr Klymenko, one of the experts in the Dynasty case was threatened: she was pressured not to complete her valuation of the estates in Kozyn. 

This is why NABU and SAPO have been calling for a separate forensic center for several years now. This article looks at the problems such a center could solve. 

Ukraine’s partners are also aware that forensic examinations in high-level corruption cases need to improve. In its 2026 enlargement report on Ukraine, the European Commission lists among its recommendations for the next 12 months the adoption of a law on anti-corruption bodies’ access to high-quality forensic examinations. The Rule of Law Roadmap likewise stresses that the NABU needs effective access to impartial, timely, and high-quality forensic examinations. 

Problems with forensic examinations remain one of the main challenges the NABU and the SAPO face in investigating high-level corruption. Contradictory calculations, years of waiting for expert opinions, and numerous reports of pressure on experts lead to repeat examinations, suspended trials, and failure to prove the amount of damages. Draft Law No. 15569, registered in the Verkhovna Rada in August of this year, proposes a solution. 

Below, we look at the problems with forensic examinations that have already arisen in NABU and SAPO proceedings and how the draft law could address them.

 

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(175) "The European Commission lists among its recommendations for the next 12 months the adoption of a law on anti-corruption bodies’ access to high-quality forensic examinations." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

The European Commission lists among its recommendations for the next 12 months the adoption of a law on anti-corruption bodies’ access to high-quality forensic examinations.

In court: repeat examinations and suspended proceedings

The consequences of these problems are most visible in the courtroom. When the parties submit conflicting expert opinions, the court has to order repeat examinations and wait for their results. 

In the case of the alleged misappropriation of more than UAH 55 million from Ukrspyrt, for example, contradictions between expert opinions led to the trial being suspended. On February 26, 2026, the HACC ordered a repeat commodity examination because the opinions submitted by the prosecution and the defense contradicted each other, and questioning the experts did not resolve the discrepancies. The repeat examination was assigned to the Bokarius Forensic Science Institute. However, the institute reported a heavy workload: its experts were handling more than ten examinations at once, so a new opinion would take over 90 calendar days. On April 30, the HACC suspended the proceedings until the examination was completed.

The HACC Appeals Chamber’s verdict in the case of Oleksii Basan, former director of the Poltava Region Local Roads Agency, describes an even more complicated situation. There, the appeals court found flaws in the opinions of both parties. The defense expert used data that was not in the case file, while the prosecution expert could not explain, when questioned, the regulatory basis for some of the calculations. In addition, the prosecution’s opinion combined two different methods of valuing the design and estimate documentation.

Questioning the experts did not resolve the contradictions, so the appeals court ordered a new comprehensive examination. But that examination also failed to establish the amount of damages, partly because of flaws in the design documentation under review. Basan was acquitted of abuse of office but found guilty of misuse of budget funds.

The Basan case showed how much depends on sound source data and a well-justified choice of methodology at the very start of an examination. These determine whether a repeat examination, which takes additional time, will be needed. And that is not all: whether such an assessment is possible at all also depends on the quality of the materials provided.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(195) "The consequences of these problems are most visible in the courtroom. When the parties submit conflicting expert opinions, the court has to order repeat examinations and wait for their results. " ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

The consequences of these problems are most visible in the courtroom. When the parties submit conflicting expert opinions, the court has to order repeat examinations and wait for their results. 

When damages cannot be proven: the Zolotariov case

The case of former Ukrzaliznytsia official Oleh Zolotariov is a particularly vivid example of the problems with forensic examinations. The expert opinions in this case gave opposite answers on whether the price of the equipment had been inflated. Questioning the experts in May, June, and July 2024 did not resolve the contradictions.

On September 4, 2024, the court ordered a comprehensive forensic economic and commodity examination. Its findings also failed to establish the market value of the equipment and, consequently, the difference between that value and the procurement price.

In its verdict of July 14, 2026, the HACC also examined in detail the flaws in the prosecution’s original examination. Among other things, to determine market value, the experts had relied on cost-price calculations and information that the court did not accept as a proper reflection of the market.

Earlier in this case, the prosecutor withdrew from the prosecution because the court-ordered examination had been unable to establish the value of the equipment, a mandatory element for assessing the amount of damage. The prosecution was then pursued by the victim alone. The court acquitted Zolotariov, and on October 27, the Appeals Chamber upheld the verdict.

In this case, acquittal was the logical outcome of the trial. Once the examination findings were challenged, it was simply impossible to prove the amount of damages, which was precisely what the prosecution had to do.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(246) "The case of former Ukrzaliznytsia official Oleh Zolotariov is a particularly vivid example of the problems with forensic examinations. The expert opinions in this case gave opposite answers on whether the price of the equipment had been inflated." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

The case of former Ukrzaliznytsia official Oleh Zolotariov is a particularly vivid example of the problems with forensic examinations. The expert opinions in this case gave opposite answers on whether the price of the equipment had been inflated.

Two prices from one institution: contradictory and possibly falsified opinions

Contradictory opinions occur even within a single forensic institution. According to SAPO Head Oleksandr Klymenko, in the case of the misappropriation of land near Fastiv, one plot was first valued at UAH 1.5 million and then at UAH 219,000. Such discrepancies affected all 462 plots in the case. They arose from the use of different comparable properties and valuation coefficients.

The court must be able to understand why an expert relied on particular data in preparing an opinion and how that data relates to the property under review. The results of an examination depend directly on the choice of comparables and methodology.

Some cases have already become the subject of investigations into the alleged falsification of expert opinions. On October 16, 2026, the NABU and the SAPO announced that experts at the Kyiv Scientific Research Institute of Forensic Expertise had been served with notices of suspicion over their valuation of real estate linked to the case of Illia Vitiuk, former head of the SSU Cybersecurity Department. According to the investigation, an apartment purchased for UAH 21.6 million was valued at UAH 12.3 million in an opinion commissioned by the defense, which used inappropriate comparable properties. 

Detectives withdrew another examination in this case, but the experts allegedly completed it later and backdated it. The NABU obtained a copy of the document from the suspect’s lawyer. These circumstances remain the investigation’s version of events and have yet to be verified.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(241) "Contradictory opinions occur even within a single forensic institution. According to SAPO Head Oleksandr Klymenko, in the case of the misappropriation of land near Fastiv, one plot was first valued at UAH 1.5 million and then at UAH 219,000." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

Contradictory opinions occur even within a single forensic institution. According to SAPO Head Oleksandr Klymenko, in the case of the misappropriation of land near Fastiv, one plot was first valued at UAH 1.5 million and then at UAH 219,000.

Years of waiting: how examinations drag out investigations

The contradictions in expert opinions are compounded by how long it takes to prepare them. 

According to the SAPO head, in the Hladkovskyi case concerning the procurement of altimeters for military aircraft, each computer forensic examination took 2.5 to 3.5 years. He said it is no longer possible to hold the experts in that case liable for a possibly false opinion, because the limitation period has expired.

In the Shuliavka overpass case, waiting for the expert opinion on damages effectively blocked the investigation. In another case, a state institution took more than 16 months to complete eight valuation and construction examinations.

Such delays affect the ability to gather and verify evidence within a reasonable time. They also prolong uncertainty for defendants and victims and increase the state’s costs of the proceedings.

array(3) { ["quote_image"]=> bool(false) ["quote_text"]=> string(196) "Such delays affect the ability to gather and verify evidence within a reasonable time. They also prolong uncertainty for defendants and victims and increase the state’s costs of the proceedings." ["quote_author"]=> string(0) "" }

Such delays affect the ability to gather and verify evidence within a reasonable time. They also prolong uncertainty for defendants and victims and increase the state’s costs of the proceedings.

Experts need protection from interference

Alongside the quality and speed of examinations, there is the question of the experts’ own safety.

As mentioned at the outset, in the Dynasty cooperative case, expert Tetiana Radkivska was tasked with valuing unfinished buildings. As Pavlo Yershov, head of a NABU detective unit, told Suspilne, in February 2026 an unknown man threatened her with the loss of her forensic expert certificate and other consequences.

In March, another man approached Radkivska near her home and said: “Why are you doing this? You know how this could end, don’t you?” The expert also reported signs of attempts to break into her car and the alarm going off at her office.

 In May, NABU Director Kryvonos confirmed at a briefing that a separate criminal case had been opened into the alleged pressure on the expert. He described the possible involvement of SSU officers as a version that the investigation is examining.

 In the case of the alleged misappropriation of UAH 141 million from Ukrzaliznytsia, investigators recorded conversations about paying for the “right” expert opinions. After a private expert was brought in, the defense sought disciplinary action against him and tried to obtain protected information about him through the court.

Clearly, an expert must be able to explain and defend their professional opinion in court. For that, they also need effective mechanisms for reporting threats and a prompt response to attempts to interfere with their work.

How legislative changes could change this practice

 Members of Parliament understand the problems NABU faces in accessing independent, timely, and high-quality forensic examinations. That is why a draft law to address them was registered in Parliament in August. 

As TI Ukraine has previously noted, the draft law provides for reorganizing an existing Ministry of Justice center into an independent institution with special safeguards for its work. These include a competition for the director’s position involving a five-member Supervisory Board (three of whose members will represent international partners), separate funding, and periodic audits.

The draft law also proposes automatic allocation of examinations among experts, priority handling of examinations in NABU and SAPO cases, and a baseline deadline of 60 days per examination, with the possibility of extension. 

For experts, the draft law also provides for higher minimum base salaries. In addition, the content of the methodologies used for examinations must be made public (except for restricted information), so that parties to a case can assess whether those methodologies were followed. At present, the Register of Methodologies contains only a list of them. This prevents the defense, the prosecution, and the court from checking how an opinion was reached and whether the examination complied with the established rules.

These mechanisms could reduce administrative influence over who conducts an examination, make deadlines more predictable, and strengthen accountability for how the work is organized. The practical result will depend on the professionalism of the staff and on the institution being properly resourced.

That said, in our view, the draft law needs some further work. 

First, the Center’s competence should be extended to all criminal proceedings that the NABU may investigate. Moreover, the draft law does not specify how quickly or in what way the institution must respond when an expert reports interference with their work. 

The educational requirement for members of the center’s Supervisory Board should also be clarified, since “forensic science” is not a separate field of study or specialty in the current official list. As a result, it is unclear what kind of degree would meet this requirement.

***

These examples show that forensic examination in high-level corruption cases is not a technical formality. It is where investigations and trials often get stuck. 

In court, conflicting expert opinions from the parties lead to repeat examinations and suspended proceedings. At worst, they make it impossible to prove the amount of damages, as in the Zolotariov case, which ended in acquittal. At the pre-trial stage, investigations wait years for expert opinions, and in the meantime limitation periods expire, including for liability for possibly false opinions.

On top of quality and timeliness, there is the problem of safety. Experts working on sensitive cases come under pressure. And when the same institution values the same plot first at UAH 1.5 million and then at UAH 219,000, it can be genuinely difficult for the court and the parties to make sense of the difference. The institution’s independence, transparent methodologies, and the protection of experts are therefore parts of a single problem.

The draft law registered in Parliament offers a systemic response to these problems: an independent institution with a competitively selected director, automatic allocation of examinations, a baseline 60-day deadline, and open methodologies. But the result will depend on whether lawmakers build real safeguards into the law for all NABU proceedings and for the protection of experts, and whether the institution receives genuinely qualified staff and adequate funding.

In any case, we believe these proposals should be considered as soon as possible. The quality of high-level corruption investigations and Ukraine’s overall progress in fighting corruption depend on these changes.