October brought three criminal proceedings for TI Ukraine’s DOZORRO program, all opened after we referred cases to law enforcement. They concern the repair of an apartment building in Dnipro, the construction of a shelter in Kharkiv Region, and the repair of water supply networks in Izmail. Across these procurements, our analysts calculated UAH 10.3 million in likely overpayments.
Criminal proceedings were not October’s only result. Over the month, contracting authorities reduced contract values by UAH 77.1 million. Contracts worth another UAH 13.4 million were terminated, and procurements worth UAH 6.7 million were canceled. In total, the DOZORRO team saved UAH 107.5 million. This figure also includes the likely overpayments that led to the criminal proceedings.
Here are October’s most notable stories.
Dnipro rejected inflated-price findings, so the police took up the case
In May 2026, the Housing Department of Dnipro City Council ordered major repairs to the apartment building at 2 Bohdana Khmelnytskoho Street. The UAH 36.9 million contract went to Starbudkontrakt LLC, the only bidder. By December 20 of this year, the company is to insulate the facade and repair the roof and other structural elements.
DOZORRO analysts reviewed the cost estimate and calculated a likely overpayment of UAH 2.8 million. The biggest potential loss, UAH 1.2 million, was on mineral wool boards. In June, we asked the Housing Department to revise the material prices. This was possible because the contract price was dynamic and could be adjusted while the works were under way.
The contracting authority, however, disagreed with our findings. It argued that comparing cost-estimate prices with offers from Kyiv suppliers was incorrect, since the works were being carried out in Dnipro. The analysis, it said, should have accounted for regional prices, volumes, lead times, and terms of supply. It also called our sample limited and unrepresentative.
Since the Department had already made partial payments under the contract, DOZORRO re-analyzed the material prices in October. Several months had passed since the previous analysis, and the market price of some items had risen. Under the updated calculations, the likely overpayment came to UAH 2.06 million, almost 6% of the contract value. Our experts then turned to law enforcement. That same month, the police reported that, based on our referral, they had entered the information into the Unified Register of Pre-Trial Investigations and opened a pre-trial investigation, which is still ongoing.
Our team counted UAH 2.06 million toward October’s savings.
In Kharkiv Region, law enforcement is investigating a possible overpayment on shelter construction
In Blyzniuky, Kharkiv Region, a shelter is being built on the grounds of the central district hospital. In December 2025, the settlement council signed a UAH 84.7 million contract with Project Alliance LLC. The same day, the contract value was reduced to UAH 80.6 million. The company is to complete construction by the end of 2027.
In May 2026, analysts reviewed the cost estimate and calculated a likely overpayment of UAH 7.4 million on construction materials. The largest share, UAH 1.2 million, was on B15 (M200) concrete. The contract price, though, was dynamic.
The DOZORRO team asked Blyzniuky Settlement Council to bring the prices into line with the market. The contracting authority rejected our calculations. In June, it explained that the contractor itself had analyzed the market value of the materials, and that the contract price had been agreed on the basis of approved design and cost estimate documentation and a positive expert review report. Yet, as DOZORRO established, the expert review does not check construction material prices. It checks only whether the overall costs are justified.
The contracting authority called our analysis unrepresentative. It argued that comparing individual cost-estimate items with market offers, without considering material specifications, logistics, and other expenses, does not prove inflated prices. However, the document listing material resource prices does not show transport costs separately, so we asked how delivery had been factored into the estimate. The contracting authority also assured us that it would pay only for work actually completed.
These arguments did not resolve the analysts’ concerns about material prices. In October, they updated their calculations, which put the likely overpayment at UAH 6.4 million. As payments had already been made under the contract, our experts wrote to law enforcement. Following our referral, the police entered the information into the URPTI and opened a pre-trial investigation.
Three water main repairs in Izmail: prosecutors investigate possible overpayments
Another story comes from Izmail, Odesa Region, where UAH 18.7 million was contracted to repair three sections of the water main. In February 2026, the Housing and Utilities Directorate of Izmail City Council signed three contracts with SMU-56 LLC. The company is to repair the water supply networks on Ukrainskoho Frontu Street and on two sections of Starokiliiska Street, for UAH 6.5 million, UAH 6.1 million, and UAH 6.1 million, respectively. All three contracts have a dynamic price.
Reviewing the cost estimates, DOZORRO analysts found likely inflated prices in all three contracts. We calculated a possible overpayment of UAH 888,000 under the first, UAH 636,000 under the second, and UAH 772,000 under the third. Concerns centered on the prices of crushed stone, pipes, sand, and concrete. In total, the water main repairs may have been overpaid by UAH 2.3 million.
To prevent these losses, the DOZORRO team sent the contracting authority three requests to revise the prices and bring them in line with the market. The letters also mentioned possible overpayments in other procurements by the Directorate. Still, the contracting authority never lowered the prices of the materials we flagged to average market levels. In replies to other DOZORRO requests about similar procurements, the Directorate blamed the high prices on a difficult logistics situation, even though transport costs were provided for separately in the estimates.
Meanwhile, payments had already been made under the contracts, and the questions about material prices had not gone away. So in October, DOZORRO updated its calculations and reported a possible overpayment of UAH 1.9 million to law enforcement. The prosecutor’s office then reported that, based on our referral, it had entered the information into the URPTI and opened a pre-trial investigation.
What else the DOZORRO team did in October
DOZORRO analysts also kept reviewing new procurements. In October, the team analyzed 106 procurements with a total estimated value of UAH 5.6 billion. Problems turned up in 79 of them, almost three quarters of those reviewed.
Most often, these were likely inflated prices. Analysts identified such risks in 67 procurements, with potential overpayments totaling UAH 116.1 million. In another 12, they found different issues, in particular with the publication of information and documents and the evaluation of tender proposals. Based on these analyses, the DOZORRO team sent 72 requests.
The results of this work are not always visible right away. Sometimes contracting authorities revise prices and reduce contract values shortly after our requests. In other cases, we have to follow procurements for months, recheck cost estimates, and, where there are grounds, turn to law enforcement. That is exactly what happened in the three stories above. So we continue to track October’s procurements and contracting authorities’ responses. Some of these requests may well bear fruit in the coming months.
This material is funded by the European Union. Its content is the sole responsibility of Transparency International Ukraine and does not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.